Showing posts with label Fraser Balmain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fraser Balmain. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 June 2014

Young Players End of Term Update

In January, after the farcical premature end to the LV Cup game against Quins I pondered on the subject of game time for young players.  Did we stack up?  Was it a problem?  Whose fault was it?

Well with the season finished and no warm trophy glow to keep us satisfied over the summer I've decided to re-vist the subject.

First of all let's look at the updated Tigers' numbers:


What's changed from January then?  We've upped the numbers of young players across the board; all three competitions saw increased use of under 23 players.  The return of Manu Tuilagi is largely responsible, in January he had only played 78 Premiership minutes, since his February return he has been an ever present.

Others have come to the fore; Fraser Balmain has seen his stock rise from 90 Prem minutes to 322, Pablo Matera from 70 to 300 as he settled in to the club.  Tiziano Pasquali and Harry Thacker have both seen Premiership debuts.

Pasquali was the youngest prop in the 3 major European leagues to see league action this season, even if he was only used for 13 minutes.

But we've also seen the fringe youngsters leave with depressing regularity.  6 of the 18 player used move on to pastures new.  Joe Cain has retired; Wells, Steele, Dunn, Purdy and Humphreys have all been released.  None were deemed worthy of Premiership starts but decisions are being made on these players earlier than ever.

Wells is only 20 years old, Ed Slater was 23 when he arrived from Australia, what would 3 years of development do for him?  

Even at this level there is a salary cap.  The club is allowed to spend £200k on players under 24 who earn under £30k, otherwise they count in the senior cap.  Manu is obviously beyond that as surely are Owen Williams and Pablo Matera.  But there is a good chance that the others are part of this cap, alongside the generation below like Brugnara, Hubbert, Milne and Tresidder.  

Domestically we still sit bottom of the table but the gap has been closed:

Back in January Tigers had almost half the ratio of younger players than any other.

Wasps lead the way but 20% of their total is Joe Launchbury and 40% of their minutes are taken up by players in the final year of qualification. 

Harlequins have used 17 different players under the age of 23 in the Premiership and 20% of game time is taken up by these players.  

But again they are heavily skewed to the top end with the 8 players born September 1990 to August 1991 constituting 71% of their under 23 minutes.  

Exeter's numbers are perhaps the most interesting.  They have gone for a limited number of players gaining lots of minutes.  Only 6 young players have been used in the league but 5 of them have played more minutes than Fraser Balmain.  Cowan-Dickie, Hill, Slade, Nowell and Ewers seem to be the nucleus of a new Exeter.


Europe wide only 7 French teams played their youngsters less often than we did, including double winners Toulon.  Ospreys were Europe leaders with 36.75% of game time going to under 23 year olds.

Who is likely to come through in the future?  Balmain and Pasquali have been talked up by Cockerill in the Mercury, Thacker continues to impress in his opputunities.  Many have been concerned about the lack of chances given to Javiah Pohe and George Catchpole, especially during the injury crisis in the centres this season.

But given another year of development they will be better when their chance comes.  Only 8 backs born in 1994 or '95 played more than one league game last season.

It would take a special kind of optimist to claim that Tigers are on the cusp of unearthing another generation of world class talent but do we really need one?  The majority of our key players are under 30 and coming into their prime.  

Ben Youngs, Tom Youngs, Dan Cole, Logo Mulipola, Marcos Ayerza, Geoff Parling, Tom Croft, Vereniki Goneva and Manu Tuilagi are all world class with plenty of time ahead of them.  Ed Slater, Pablo Matera, Steve Mafi, Graham Kitchener and Miles Benjamin are all young and full of potential to join them soon.

Key signings to this group with the aim of greater glory in the new Champions Cup seems like a better priority than blooding youngsters for the sake of it.

Wednesday, 17 April 2013

Front Row Double at Players' Player of the Year Awards

The Front Row Union celebrated a double victory last night as Tom Youngs was voted as Players' Player of the Year and Fraser Balmain won the Players' Young Player of Year. 

Hooker Tom Youngs has played 20 times for the first team this season (including pre-season friendlies against Nottingham and Ulster) and will make his 50th first appearance since his 2006 debut in his next game.  

Youngs was an age grade international center only transferring to the hooking berth on the suggestion of Heyneke Meyer in 2008.  He then spent the best part of 3 season on loan at Midlands rivals Nottingham playing 42 games as he learned his craft in England's second tier.

Last season he didn't start a Premiership game but featured off the bench in the Final against Harlequins and was called up to England's tour to South Africa where he started both mid week matches.  Going from strength to strength after that tour Tom secured the starting shirt for Tigers first game of the season, away to London Welsh, where he set up a try for Thomas Waldrom.  

Injuries to others gave him his chance in an England shirt and after only 9 starts in either league or Europe for Leicester he was lining up at Twickenham for his England debut against Fiji, starts against Australia and South Africa followed before Youngs started in England's record win against the All Blacks.  He was an ever present in the 6 Nations and now has 9 caps with 8 of them starts.

Fraser Balmain is a 21 year old from Newcastle comfortable on either side of the scrum.  He came off the bench twice last season before spending a month in Clermont-Ferrand as part of the two clubs Academy Exchange programme.  This period seems to have helped Balmain kick on as he has over taken other young props first to start regularly for the A League side and then to make his Premiership debut against Exeter in September.

It was Balmain's first start that really caught the eye though as he impressed in both the scrum and the lose during the win against the touring New Zealand Maori side, their first loss for 5 years.  His first Premiership start was 12 days later against Wasps at Adams Park and though the result was not what was wanted young Balmain reinforced his burgeoning reputation.

At 17 Newcastle decided they didn't want to offer Balmain a professional deal, so his coach at the city's Royal Grammar School sent off his highlights DVD to both Leicester and Northampton; Saints offered a 3 month deal but Tigers risked a full year and have been amply rewarded.

Wednesday, 28 November 2012

10 to watch in 2013


As Christmas and the New Year approaches we here at the UltraSubmarines are being constantly asked "Who do you think are the Top 10 to watch during 2013"?  In the supermarket people are stopping us beside the fish counter, in the pub people are jostling to the bar to talk our ears off and Christmas shopping has become a nightmare as shoppers from Fenwicks to John Lewis are desperate to talk Tigers.  So to save us the bother and give us 5 minutes of respite from the onslaught of queries our panel of experts have come up with the definitive list of 10 players to watch during 2013.

1. George Ford
An obvious one, after all what self respecting pundit isn’t proclaiming him the best thing since sliced bread?  We’d temper expectations just a bit by saying he reminds us more of a young Andy Goode than Dan Carter or Jonny Wilkinson; capable of moments of sumptuous genius that have a Houdini like ability to unlock the tightest of defences but also capable of the downright stinking.  Still a young man at 19 it is 4 seasons since he made his debut away to Leeds in the LV cup, which made him the youngest player in Leicester’s history and that of professional rugby, he has come so far but still has a long way to go.  People keep saying next year will be his year; well 2013 will be his year!


2. Fraser Balmain
The Geordie prop has come from nowhere to make a big impact jumping ahead of Ryan Bower and Kieran Brookes in the young prop stakes.  Balmain made his league debut in the recent game away to Wasps and acquitted himself well, but the game that really announced him to the Rugby world was the Maori match 12 days earlier where he was part of a dominant scrum.  Last year he wasn’t even getting starts in the A team but a 2 month spell on loan to Clermont seems to have made a man of him and he has been a different beast ever since.  Signed at 18 after Newcastle passed on him the Newcastle Royal Grammer School graduate chose Tigers over our rivals the Saints and in 2013 we are just about to see the benefits. 


3. Jimmy Stevens
Cornish hooker Jimmy Stevens joined the academy at 17 from Redruth and hasn’t looked back.  Terrific in the loose and accomplished at the set pieces Stevens has earned comparisons with his veteran club mate George Chuter.  Stevens has made 6 first team appearances since his debut against Aironi in the Heineken Cup last January and has looked comfortable in them all.  He has made 4 appearances this season including his first two Premiership appearances; against Exeter at home and then away to Sale the next week.  Originally from St.Ives Stevens will look to oust Rob Hawkins from third choice at hooker and also look at over taking George Chuter to become Tom Youngs understudy by the end of 2013.


4. Michael Noone
Nicknamed Perfect (as in No one’s perfect) and capable of playing both 6 & 8 Noone made an immediate impression after joining the club from Doncaster over the summer.  Man of the Match in his first game for the Extras he scored 3 tries in 4 games at that level before grabbing another try on his first team debut away to Saracens and setting one up at home to London Irish, both in the LV Cup.  An Irish international throughout the age groups the Killiney man played for Leinster A but never cracked the main side which prompted the move to Doncaster.  Standing well over 6 foot he carries like a wrecking ball and looks like another great bit of scouting by the club.


5. Joe Cain
20 year old Joe “Co” Cain is a second row with a burgeoning reputation.  He grabbed a try on his first team debut in the LV Cup, like so many in this list away to Saracens, to go along with 4 starts for the Extras this year and 3 the year before.  From just across the county border into Derbyshire, the Burton boy is a nephew of football manager Phil Brown and came through Melbourne’s junior system.  A great reader of the game he always seems to be in the right place at the right time.  2013 might be a bit early for him as he finds his way in the game but he is sure to go far.


6. Scott Steele
Scottish Under 20s scrum half Steele made a big impact last season after a successful summer trial.  The Dumfries man had been over looked by Glasgow when Tigers stepped into the breach to sweep him up.  A typically physical Scottish scrum half Steele has an accurate pass and a boot that could kick the chaps off a cowboy.  He came off the bench in last year’s LV Cup semi final against Bath and also made his Premiership debut against Newcastle during the 6 Nations.  Son of an international referee his immediate aim will be to make the Under 20 World Cup after missing last years with a cruel leg break; after that he will have his eyes firmly set on taking Sam Harrison’s spot in the match day 23 and also getting full Scotland caps.


7. Andy Symons
Originally a Saracens minis player during a stint in New Zealand with Christchurch’s High School Old Boys he came on to Tigers radar thanks to his coach in New Zealand, one Aaron Mauger!  He made a strong early impression and earned a debut away to Llanelli in the LV Cup, only to break his leg and miss the rest of the season.  A huge specimen he stands over 6 foot and weighs in at 16 and a half stone, with that obviously comes strong ball carrying but the polish applied to his game in Christchurch is evident with his wide range of passes.  Defensively sound, he has a tough job to get ahead of Dan Bowden and Anthony Allen but he has all the skills and just requires some game time.


8. Javiah Pohe
Born in New Zealand to a Cornish mother the family moved back to the Duchy when Pohe was 11.  Like Stevens he played for Redruth before making the move up to the Midlands at 15.  His father now coaches Melton’s first team and is a Tigers community coach.  Pohe impressed in England colours during last year’s FIRA-AER Under 18 championship with his swashbuckling runs which he has also shown during his limited game time in the second team.  A strong centre reminiscent of a young Manu Tuilagi he has all the attributes of a modern centre and could be a bolter in 2013 as physically he is already up to the man’s game, not surprising given he was a prop when playing Rugby League in New Zealand.


9. Henry Purdy
A summer signing from Wasps 18 year old Purdy made an immediate impact for the second team as he bagged 6 tries in 4 starts from the right wing.  Purdy is equally comfortable at centre where last season he played for England U-18s against Leicester and combines devastating pace with impressive physicality in contact.  As his stats bear out his best attribute is his nose for a try, he has the knack of finding his way to the line is like a pig has for finding truffles.  A former schoolboy at Cokethorpe, near Oxford, he made his first team debut in the LV Cup away to Saracens and will be looking to push on to England U-20 honours and more first team games in 2013.


10.Niall Morris
2013 could be Morris’s year to establish him in the Tigers first choice back three.  Injuries to his rivals and Geordan Murphy’s presumed impending retirement have given him the chance and he has taken it with both hands.  He has pace to burn as he showed on his debut against Exeter, where he bagged a brace, and is also comfortable on the wing.  As befits an Irish full back he is secure under the high ball and posses a raking kick.  At Leinster he found it hard to break through due to the quality ahead of him despite scoring 3 tries in 3 starts but since the move to Leicester he has blossomed under countryman Geordan Murphy’s expert eye and 2013 looks set to be his year.

Thursday, 22 November 2012

An Ode to Balmain

Fraser the Razor 


Fraser the razor gonna shock and amaze yer
Going to gut you like a thief in the night
The Balmain man, You know that he can
Going to scrum you with all of his might

Geordie? Sure. 
He’s always ready for more
The Balmain train brings a hurricane of pain
To the props in the main
But the rest all the same.

When he carries the ball he’ll beat one, beat them all!
His rucking will give you a fright
And when the ball’s in the maul he plays ten feet tall
It really is quite a sight.

Wednesday, 14 November 2012

ABC Some More Maori Thoughts



A. Maori Magic can define the rest of our season
The Maori match was an historic occasion and a great match; it was well worth my £20 and well worth whatever the club paid them to appear.  But more than that it can now be referred to as a focal point for two very different styles of Rugby football.  Our rucking was a world apart, the modern ruck was invented in Otago but Louis Deacon and co. brought it to a new level against its inheritants.  I can’t remember too many Heineken Cup matches fought with such intensity at the breakdown and this match could be a powerful aide memoir when the heat comes on, whether that is away to Ospyres, at home to Toulouse or hopefully beyond, we can now summon up the spirit of this match to know deep down in the seat of your pants that we CAN go the extra mile.

And also we must look at some of the Maori play and draw inspiration from it.  Their ball retention was very good and the support work was magnificent.  If we can get our forwards in particular flooding the channel looking for the quick pass we could become an attacking juggernaut.  Pat Howard’s team was probably the best Tigers side at this and it is where some of the top teams like Leinster and Quins have the wood on us.

B. Balmain proves doubters wrong.
Fraser Balmain’s debut must have prompted some red faces in Newcastle.  The ex RGS pupil was branded “nothing more than a good local player” and not even offered a contract when he finished school 3 years ago.  Thankfully Tigers scouts had more about them and won the battle for his signature with Northampton.  It is hard to fathom how any scout could come to that conclusion after watching him destroy the Maori scrum, it goes to show your academy is only as strong as your scouts!

C. Tait is great but Niall is the Full back business.
Matt Tait made his first start for 13 months and at the less than usual position of full back.  He showed what a class player he was with some lovely touches and some ferocious tackles; but also showed why he isn’t the successor to Geordan Murphy.  Letting several balls bounce will be punished on other occasions and his position for other kicks was poor.  The less said about his kicking the better.

You can’t be too hard on a players come back game, but when the rest of his performance was so good the errors stood out even more.  In the second half he switched with his winger Niall Morris and looked far more comfortable getting stuck in to the action.  These two together could provide a tandem partnership in the vein of Stimpson and Murphy if they fulfil their promise.

Wednesday, 17 October 2012

A League seasons ends with victory

The official Aviva A League season is already over, just 7 weeks into the season, as Tigers Extras have failed to progress to the semi finals stage.  Gloucester beat Northampton to ensure both sides progressed at Kingsholm on Monday night.

In the last round of fixtures Tigers traveled to Sale with a strong side featuring both Deacon brothers and Matt Tait.  They romped to a 10 try 61-20 victory with a hat trick from burgeoning winger Alex Lewington and a brace from the impressive Irishman Michael Noone.  Other scores came from Andy Forsyth, Henry Purdy, Micky Young, Matt Tait and Pat Phibbs.  Matt Cornwell added 11 points with the boot.

Over the course of the 5 game season Tigers used 43 players, with 31 different starter, 9 have been involved in all 5 games but only 3 players (Matt Cornwell, Fraser Balmain and Alex Lewington) have started every game.  11 players have featured a single time, from Louis Deacon and George Chuter at one end of the spectrum to Tom Bellak and George Oliver at the other.

Top try scorer has been summer signing from Wasps Henry Purdy who has touched down 6 times in only 4 starts.  Alex Lewington scored 4 and Michael Noone scored 3.  Matt Cornwell notched 20 conversions from 31 attempts and was also succesful with 2 penalties for a grand total of 46 points.  Overall 17 players a scored a try and a penalty try was also scored when Alex Lewington was taken out with the line begging.

Tigers outscored their opponents 201 to 142 points over the 5 games, including winning the try battle 31 to 17.

This has been a mixed season for Tigers Extras.  They lost against the only 2 decent sides they faced but romped to massive victories against the weaklings in the group.  They looked pretty handy in the two home games I saw but the standard of the competition has collapsed from a high point of the mid noughties.  It used to be a better standard than the Championship but now resides somewhere around National League 1's mid table.  So it is very difficult where to place even the standout players like Henry Purdy, Alex Lewington or the two young props Fraser Balmain or Kieran Brookes.  Are they ready for the first team or not?  Who knows and with Cockerill's less than progressive use of the academy we may never find out.  It's definitely a grim life for the ones that struggle at this level.

Really the A league has evolved into a joke tournament.  England is a small country and a regional competition is unnecessary and makes the competition weaker.  It is frankly a shame that Tigers can't play the likes of Harlequins, Saracens or Exeter on a regular basis and instead have to schlep to Sale to put 61 points on a side that isn't fit for competition.  Last year we put 80 points on Leeds.  We could get games as uncompetitive as that by playing Nottingham, Moseley and Bedford and save a lot of money on diesel for the team bus.  Instead the A league should move to two national divisions of 6 with promotion and relegation between the divisions, and playing a full 10 game double round robin fixture list.  This could be supplemented with friendlies and local derbies as desired by the individual clubs.  What ever happens it can't, surely, stagger on with this ridicules micro schedule for much longer.

Monday, 10 September 2012

High Noone as Tigers tame flustered Falcons.



Michael Noone made a dream start to his Tigers career as he scored a scorching breakaway try on debut. After smart work from Scott Steele turned ball over from a Newcastle scrum Noone showed the Geordie pack a clean pair of heels as he outpaced the cover defence to touch down in the left hand corner.  As the saying goes No-one is perfect!

Tigers raced away to a 7 try win securing the bonus point after only 22 minutes, as a scintillating first half hour put the Tigers way beyond the grasp of the Newcastle side.

After the first try established the lead it was never lost, on 13 minutes after heavy pressure from the forwards the otherwise unimpressive Bowden danced through the Newcastle defence to touch down under the posts.   Cornwell added the extras to make it 12-3.

Newcastle did claw a try back and it was the least they deserved for a concerted if blunt forward effort eventually relented to allow the backs the ball. It was shifted right to left and Michael Tait scored in the corner.

The next try was scored by Adam Thompstone after very strong running from the impressive Alex Lewington.  His strength through contact is reminiscant of great wingers of the past like Dave Lougheed or Horacio Agulla. 

Lewington was creator again as opposite winger Henry Purdy barged over for the bonus point try.  On the wrap around Lewington barged past 5 defenders before releasing Purdy, who still had work to do himself beating the Newcastle hooker to the line.

Purdy bagged his brace just 5 minutes later as a solid scrum fronted up by former Newcastle Royal Grammar School-Boy Fraser Balmain and former Falcon Kieran Brookes allowed Tigers an attacking platform to work from.  Morris took the ball to the line before releasing Purdy, a summer signing from Wasps academy, who beat his man on the outside possibly benefitting from no TMO as he was rapidly approaching the touchline.

Milky Bar Kid look alike Joel Hodgson slotted a penalty to round off the half.

The start of the second half has been a good time for Leicester this season with the first team bagging tries in both games so far.  The A team didn’t want to be outdone and duly had their own fast start in front of most of the first team squad, plus Tigers legends John Wells, sitting next to Geordan Murphy, and Freddie Tuilagi in deep conversation with Dean Richards.  If a stack of Samoans turn up to Newcastle in the coming weeks we will know why!  Scott Steele took the ball from a quick ruck, shifting on the Dan Bowden.  Bowden threw a trademark wide miss pass, whether he is capable of passing under 15 metres is yet to be established, to Morris who drew in more defenders before Thompstone, playing 13, had a strong finish from 20 yards.  He was brought down on the line and it wasn’t immediately clear whether he or debutant Noone had got the score.  Thompstone was awarded it and thus sealed his brace for the night.

Newcastle then laid siege to the Tigers line thanks to some refereeing that wouldn’t have been out of place in an under 14s match, fittingly as the touch judge Rob Debney was my old school teacher!  Eventually the Geordies tired of trying to force a try over and settled for another Milky Bar Kid penalty.

Tigers 7th and final try came after a lovely weighted chip from Syston’s Matt Cornwell, fresh from his spell in Mogliano, set up a Falcons line out 5 metres out.  The Geordie line out misfired all game, less so after the introduction of kiwi first team hooker Mike Mayhew but he suffered just the same this time as Tigers poached the line out.  Relentless drives resulted in Fraser Balmain being awarded a try.  Surely a good repost to the club that didn’t think him good enough at 18.

Ironically Falcons hooker George McGuigan was to profit from an over thrown lineout as he got a consolation try right at the death.  A good run from Falcon’s England group prospect Zack Kilbridge was snuffed out by a strong Matt Cornwell cover tackle, however Jimmy Stevens couldn’t find his man and the ball dropped into McGuigan’s thankful hands. 

Impressive performances:
Alex Lewington: strong carries made the difference early doors must be in line for a Premiership start soon.
 Fraser Balmain & Kieran Brookes: solid all day in the set piece and a real nuisance in the breakdown.  Responded well to a poor return last week and Balmian took his try well.

Needs to improve:
Dan Bowden: Needs to cut out the silly miss passes and focus on getting the ball through the hands.  If Allen went down today I’d rather have Matt Cornwell play 12 at Wembley.  Looked much more effective when he was more direct and using the short passes.

Man of the Match:
Has to go to Michael Noone, fantastic try to start the night off and was a real terrier the whole night.  Hopefully will sign on full time and could start pushing Waldrom and Crane for starts if this performance was anything to go by.